Witches Brew & More Halloween Punch Recipes What would a Halloween party be without witches brew? It just adds so much to the theme and feel of a great Halloween party. There are so many varieties of witches brew that you are sure to find the perfect recipe below. You can have a punch with dry ice or just throw in a couple of fake eyeballs. Either way, it is sure to be a hit! Easy Witches Brew Recipe How To Make Witches Brew Photo by Travelin' Librarian on Flickr Ingredients: 1 c. sugar 1 tsp. cinnamon 1 tsp. allspice 2 qts.